Terminating Volunteers When There’s Just No Other Option
You’ve mentioned your concern to them. You’ve emailed them friendly reminders. You’ve sat down with them to work out a plan for improvement. And they...
5 min read
Christine Spiers, CVA
Nov 19, 2026, 10:39:14 AM
Most volunteer programs work. Many just take more effort than they should. In this session, Christine Spiers, CVA shared a ten-question health check to help leaders of volunteers see what's working, what depends on workarounds, and where to focus next.
Recorded live on Tuesday, November 17, 2026. Running time: about 46 minutes, including audience Q&A.
Webinar feedback
Your feedback helps us improve future webinars and create more useful sessions for volunteer engagement professionals.
PDU credit
Complete the form to receive your Certificate of Completion, which can be used towards earning Professional Development Units (PDUs).
Session materials
Access the live chat from this session, plus a guide to help you find a system that fits how your program actually works.
Live Chat Transcript
TXT · Recording chat from the session
Volunteer Management Software Buyer's Guide 2026
Guide · Better Impact
Volunteer programs rarely struggle because people stop caring. More often, unnecessary steps build up, workarounds become normal, and processes stay the same for years because "that's how we've always done it."
When you're close to a program, these issues are hard to see. The health check is designed to give you an outside view, making hidden dependencies visible so you know where to focus first. It's useful whether you've run your program for years or have just inherited one.
The ten questions are grouped into four areas: who holds it, what you can see, how it works for volunteers, and where the effort goes. For each one, choose the answer that fits best:
Go with your first instinct. The check is for you, not for anyone else.
This question measures how much of your program depends on one person's knowledge and relationships. If the honest answer is "most of it," that reflects how the organization has been set up, not your performance. For leadership, the question becomes: which parts of the volunteer program would stop if one person left tomorrow?
You may know the answer, but would your colleagues? When volunteering sits between teams without clear accountability, each team often recruits and onboards in its own way, with no consistent process.
Think about police check and working with children check renewals, training refreshers, and incident follow-ups. If these live in someone's head instead of in your volunteer management system, they're a dependency risk. Volunteer program risks are also often missing from the organization's wider risk register.
Hours, shifts filled, and volunteer numbers show the program is busy, but not what those hours accomplish. Stronger reporting links volunteer activity to organizational goals, captures real outputs like trees planted or patients visited, and tracks health measures such as retention.
A volunteer management system plus several side spreadsheets and personal notes means double handling and no single source of truth. It also makes life much harder for whoever steps into your role next.
The real question is whether that path is mapped, documented, and current. Bringing staff from every team involved into one room often reveals steps the volunteer manager didn't know about, and opens the door to questions like: do we really need multiple reference checks for a role that doesn't involve vulnerable people?
Speed matters here, because the early weeks are when connection and belonging are built. One approach that worked well: moving from ad hoc interviews to scheduled intakes with group interviews. It streamlined recruitment, and new volunteers started their first shift already connected as a cohort.
Every role should have a description, reviewed at least every two years. Expectations have shifted toward shorter shifts and more flexibility, and outdated descriptions can create training and health and safety risks. Involving volunteers in reviews keeps descriptions accurate and gives them a real voice in the program.
Whether feedback comes from surveys or focus groups, close the loop. You won't be able to act on every suggestion, but explaining why builds trust. Silence erodes it. Attendees shared changes they'd made from volunteer feedback, including adjusted shift hours, more online training, weekly email updates, a redesigned recognition program, and volunteers helping shape new roles.
Double entry, side spreadsheets, and manual reminders show where the way you work and the way your systems work have drifted apart. That's useful information, not a failure.
When rolling out a new system or process, plan for change. Offer guides in different formats for different learning styles, and consider a small group of volunteer champions who test your resources and then support others. The ADKAR model (awareness, desire, knowledge, ability, reinforcement) is a helpful framework.
Look at which roles and processes add the most value for your organization, volunteers, and community, and which aren't linked to your goals. Consider staff time too: a role with little impact that takes a lot of staff support may be worth rethinking. Not everything needs fixing. Some things are working well and deserve protecting.
Attendees shared examples such as removing a redundant declaration step already covered by police checks, reducing sign-offs in recruitment, involving supervisors in interviews and inductions, and training staff to work with volunteers.
In a live poll, 61% of attendees said their program works with effort, and 23% said it runs smoothly. "How it works for volunteers" was the area attendees found hardest to answer, which suggests friction that's difficult to see from the inside. Involving volunteers in decisions that affect them, from role descriptions to process mapping, is the best way to bring it to light.
Look for patterns across your answers, then keep three principles in mind:
Frame what you find as an organizational issue, not a coordinator issue. Senior leaders care about risk, sustainability, and impact, and the health check gives you the language to raise those points. Start by taking one answer to your next team meeting.
Look at how many inquiries turn into registered volunteers, how long volunteers stay, grant and funding success, and volunteer satisfaction. Satisfaction rises when volunteers feel part of the organization and have a say. Systems matter too: if key knowledge leaves with one person, the next person starts from scratch.
Christine Spiers, CVA, has more than 20 years of volunteer leadership experience and seven years in consulting. A trusted Better Impact partner based in Melbourne, she works with nonprofits, councils, government agencies, peak bodies, and volunteer resource centres across Australia, New Zealand, and beyond.
Christine has used Better Impact since 2010 and holds certifications in volunteer administration, Lean Six Sigma (Green Belt), change management (Prosci), and community engagement (IAP2). Her services include system reviews, training, user guides, coaching, custom e-learning, and Volunteer Management Frameworks aligned to sector standards.
Featured Posts
You’ve mentioned your concern to them. You’ve emailed them friendly reminders. You’ve sat down with them to work out a plan for improvement. And they...
When leading a volunteer program, one of the most important tasks is presenting key information to the organization's Board of Directors. These...
The magic and the risk of founding energy There’s a special kind of magic that happens when someone is involved with an organisation from the...